Pizza restaurants

Pizza Pie (Rt. 8 location)

4.5 200 reviews Closed 1734 N Main St Ext, Butler, PA 16001, United States

Discover this place

If you're in Butler, PA, make sure to visit Pizza Pie (Rt. 8 location), located at 1734 N Main St Ext. This local gem has garnered rave reviews for its mouthwatering pizza, especially the Sicilian style, which one enthusiast claims boasts sauce imported from Italy and a delightfully flaky crust. Customers frequently tout the pizza's warmth and quality, perfect for takeout, as it arrives piping hot and ready to satisfy your cravings.

A cozy atmosphere isn't the focus here, as Patti Arnett notes, but the absence of dine-in service is offset by the superb flavor of the pizza and homemade Italian dressing for salads. Many patrons, like Jodi Douthett, appreciate the friendly service and rave about the delicious breadsticks that complement their pizza experience. Whether you're a fan of classic ham and cheese or drawn to unique toppings like anchovies, Steve reassures that Pizza Pie will not disappoint your taste buds.

So if you’re in the area or passing through, Pizza Pie is definitely worth a stop. Support local and indulge in what many claim to be the best pizza in western Pennsylvania!

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Curbside pickup
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Pizza Pie (Rt. 8 location) before visiting.

Reviews for Pizza Pie (Rt. 8 location)

4.5

200 reviews

100%

17%

11%

Review highlights

Based on 200 reviews

Pizza Pie (Rt. 8 location) in Butler, PA, is widely appreciated for its flavorful, authentic Italian-style pizzas, particularly the Sicilian and specialty options featuring generous cheese and well-balanced sauces. Customers frequently highlight the crust’s unique texture, described as flaky rather than hard, contributing to a distinctive eating experience. The restaurant is recognized for its friendly service and popular complementary items such as breadsticks and homemade dressings. While primarily known for takeout and delivery, the consistent quality and local appeal have earned it a loyal following, including praise for accommodating less common toppings like anchovies. Overall, Pizza Pie is seen as a reliable choice for those seeking hearty, traditional pizza with a focus on freshness and flavor.

Liz Fischer

Jul 15, 2025

I've never been in Pizza Pie, but we love it at base 3. Delivers hot. Sicilian is the best!!! Sauce out of Italy! Crust is flaky, not hard.

Jodi Douthett

Jul 11, 2025

This is always our go to pizza place. Friendly service, awesome pizzas and love the breadsticks!

Patti Arnett

Jun 28, 2025

Not a dine in, but the pizza is excellent!! The homemade Italian dressing for the chicken salad is superb!! My favorite pizza in Butler!

Ontario Go Local

Jun 19, 2025

Support local!! We were in Grove City for a few days and wanted to try a local pizza place. We ordered a medium ham and cheese pizza- the sauce was good and there was a lot of cheese on the pizza. It was totally worth the drive, we’ll visit again for sure!

Steve

May 19, 2025

I believe that your pizza is the best in western Pennsylvania, I love the fact that you have anchovies, most places don't anymore . Thank you , keep up the good work. A fan of PIZZA PIE.

Tom Anderson

Apr 18, 2025

I've been searching out local pizza places for a while now, and today I visited Pizza Pie on Route 8 North. The food was good, and what really stood out was the friendly staff. They were welcoming, with genuine smiles. The pizza and Italian hoagie were excellent, and the prices were reasonable compared to other options in the area. I believe I've found a new favorite place!

Curtis Mahood

Apr 09, 2025

Pizza is always perfect! The absolute best house made Italian dressing we always dip our pizza and bread sticks in! The owner is a great guy I've spent many times talking to a lot longer than the wife cared for but she got over it,!

Sidney Criley

Apr 03, 2025

Absolutely exemplary. The staff are very kind willing to stay open and few extra minutes for a last minute pickup. The pizza’s are amazing, not too greasy not just a dry frisbee, just perfect. The breadsticks are a little lack luster but still worth the price. Would recommend this or the Rt 68 location any day for your new go to pizza place!